Government

US audit says veterans mortgage relief programme lacks comprehensive evaluation plan

A federal watchdog says the Veterans Affairs Department has begun implementing foreclosure relief but needs a fuller plan to measure whether the programme works before its authorization expires.

Updated: 2 min read

The US Department of Veterans Affairs has introduced a mortgage-relief option intended to help borrowers with VA-guaranteed loans avoid foreclosure, but it has not developed a comprehensive plan to evaluate the programme's effectiveness, according to a November 10 Government Accountability Office report.

The Partial Claim Program allows a mortgage servicer to receive reimbursement from VA for a borrower's missed payments and certain fees. The borrower can then become current on the loan and repay the amount without interest when the property is sold or refinanced, the mortgage is paid off, or the loan reaches maturity.

GAO said the programme became effective on June 15, 2026, while servicers have until November 28 to complete implementation. The agency has developed policies, sought feedback, trained participants and worked on oversight and data systems. These steps establish a route to assistance but do not demonstrate that the intervention has reduced foreclosures.

The watchdog found that VA's high-level evaluation approach does not isolate the programme's impact from other factors affecting borrowers, and does not fully address design questions. VA officials said they intended to start analysing trends and outcomes in December 2027. GAO recommended developing a comprehensive evaluation plan sooner, including methods, data and criteria for assessing results.

The question matters because the programme is authorized only through July 30, 2030 unless Congress extends it. Without credible performance evidence, lawmakers may struggle to determine whether to continue or change it.

Federal Affairs Dispatch separately reported the approaching November 28 servicer deadline and the evaluation gap identified by GAO. Its reporting described the partial claim as a way for eligible borrowers to catch up on missed payments without an immediate lump-sum repayment.

The report did not conclude that the programme has failed. Rather, it found that the department should plan now to measure outcomes and costs. VA did not provide comments on the GAO report, according to the watchdog. That distinction is important: implementation progress and independently demonstrated effectiveness are different measures of public programme performance.

Spotted an error? Request a correction · Our editorial principles · Contact the newsroom