Government

UK watchdog finds government risk advisers often consulted after major decisions

A National Audit Office review finds uneven risk-management capability across Whitehall and urges leaders to involve specialists earlier in policy and spending decisions.

Updated: 2 min read

Britain's National Audit Office has warned that risk specialists in government are frequently brought into decision-making too late to shape major choices, despite improvements in central guidance and professional training. Its report, published on 18 November 2026, examined how departments and other public bodies use risk information when setting priorities and delivering services.

The watchdog said central government has strengthened its risk management foundations, including the Government Risk Profession and HM Treasury's Risk Centre of Excellence. But it found uneven adoption and limited evidence that risk professionals routinely influence organisational direction before decisions are made.

In a survey of risk professionals across government, just over half of respondents said they were usually involved too late to shape major decisions, mainly asked to check decisions already taken, or not involved at all. That finding describes the survey respondents' experience, rather than proving every government decision was made without expert advice.

The NAO identified complex and interconnected threats including cyber incidents, extreme weather, pandemics, fraud and delivery failures. It also pointed to examples of stronger practice: the Bank of England encouraged early reporting of concerns during modernisation of a critical payments system, while the UK Hydrographic Office used a dashboard to make risks and follow-up actions more visible to leaders.

Separate reporting by Civil Service World on 19 November highlighted the audit's finding that around a third of the 17 main government departments were still tracking risks manually as of September 2026. The report described differences between departments' processes and how consistently leaders used risk information.

The NAO's recommendations focus on involving specialists at the start of policy, spending and delivery decisions, strengthening senior leaders' training and creating arrangements to identify risks that cross organisational boundaries. The watchdog said some arm's-length bodies had limited contact with sponsoring departments' risk teams, making coordinated action more difficult.

The report is an assessment of management capability, not a finding of fraud or wrongdoing by named officials. Its conclusions also recognise that government bodies have made progress and that risk-taking can support innovation when decisions are properly informed.

The findings matter as more responsibilities and spending decisions are devolved to local and regional government. The audit argues that clearer leadership, earlier challenge and better cross-agency information are needed if public services are to anticipate threats rather than respond after disruption occurs.

Spotted an error? Request a correction · Our editorial principles · Contact the newsroom