Government

UK audit finds risk specialists often excluded from major government decisions

National Audit Office review says risk management practices have improved but advice often arrives too late, with uneven oversight across public bodies.

Updated: 2 min read

The United Kingdom's National Audit Office has warned that government risk specialists are frequently consulted too late to influence major decisions, despite improvements in risk-management guidance and systems. Its report, published on 18 November 2026, examined how central government bodies identify and manage risks affecting public services and spending.

The watchdog said progress has been uneven. Some departments have strengthened their tools and professional capability, but effective risk management also depends on leaders welcoming challenge and using risk assessments when setting priorities. The NAO said its review found limited evidence that advice from risk professionals regularly changed major decisions or organisational direction.

In a survey cited by the NAO, just over half of responding risk professionals said they were typically involved too late to shape major decisions, primarily asked to check decisions already taken, or not involved at all. The watchdog also identified weaknesses in the management of risks crossing organisational boundaries, including relationships with suppliers, arm's-length bodies and local authorities.

Independent reporting by Civil Service World highlighted a further operational weakness: roughly one-third of 17 principal departments were still tracking risks manually in September 2026. Separately, The Independent reported the watchdog's concern that major decisions were being made without sufficiently early specialist consultation, against a backdrop of cyber threats and extreme weather.

The report did not conclude that all government risk controls had failed. It cited examples of stronger practices, including a risk dashboard at the UK Hydrographic Office and arrangements at the Bank of England that encouraged staff to raise concerns. The NAO recommended clearer expectations for senior leaders, better practical training, and stronger arrangements to identify and escalate risks that span public bodies.

The findings are recommendations from an independent public spending watchdog, not a court judgment or a finding of wrongdoing against particular officials. Their significance lies in whether departments incorporate risk advice before committing to major policies and programmes rather than treating it as a final compliance check.

Spotted an error? Request a correction · Our editorial principles · Contact the newsroom